Some say that the wicked are utterly destroyed and cease to exist, while others believe in eternal damnation maimonides, mishneh torah, law of repentance, 3. Torah from heaven the reconstruction of faith norman solomon. Heaven and hell in jewish tradition my jewish learning. The jewish week, september 2005 jewish week book page. To rephrase the last point, god has limitations or. The fourth heaven is ruled by the archangel michael, and according to talmud hagiga 12, it contains the heavenly jerusalem, the temple, and the altar. Though they are both religious manuscripts, they are two totally different things. Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled. We cannot make that determination by comparing this book with the other books, which we know god has produced. Written in a personal and accessible style, the focus is on judaism but the arguments are easy to transpose to other religions. As is clear from this brief discussion, the jewish tradition contains a variety of opinions on the subjects of heaven and hell.
Your book offers on average two essays on each of the weekly torah portions, written originally as standalone weekly divrei torah sermons. If god composed the torah then there is no room for the dh, even a prophetic dh, that deduces multiple authors from the text. Each of the people experienced heaven after dying a. Manna is from heaven, according to the hebrew bible and to jesus in the new testament, but the various identifications of manna are naturalistic. Published over many years in hebrew, it has now been made available in clear, idiomatic english continuum, 2005.
An illuminated torah commentary pomegranate is brilliantly imaginative and magnificent. Best known for his role in the civil rights and peace movements of. The giving of the ten commandments, the revelation at sinai, was a unique moment, not only in jewish history but in the religious history of mankind, the only time when god is spoken of as speaking to an entire nation. Rabbi dov peretz elkins jewish stories from heaven and earth. Afterlife in tanakh there is a paucity of explicit references to afterlifewhether a bodily resurrection or a soul worldin tanakh. In their simplest form, the twentyfour books of the jewish bible the tanach present a history of the first 3500 years from creation until the building of the second temple in jerusalem. In parashat vayelekh we read of the writing of the torah. It was said in a number of wonderful books on art by the great ernst gombrich. In fact, the torah seems to be a mediocre book compared to the great works of the greeks and other philosophers. The books also relate the history of the jewish nation from its earliest stage, through the giving of the law at mount sinai, and until the end of the first commonwealth.
The hebraic book of revelation part 4 torah to the tribes. The littman library of jewish civilization in association with liverpool university press. These are two of the most important words in all of jewish history. The torah promises thisworldly rewards and punishments for faithfulness or lack thereof to god and the torah. Unusual discovery concerning characteristics of the hebrew text of the torah. It can most specifically mean the first f ive bo oks pentateuch or five books of moses of the 24 book s of th e hebrew bible. Kuhn in his book the structure of scientific revolutions. The lamb that rides the white horse and offers the invitation to.
I saw the dead, great and small, standing before the throne, and books were opened. The concept of torah from heaven means that god wrote the words of the torah. The torah is a human invention and does not carry any divinity. The final book of the torah, deuteronomy, presents itself as mosess speech, not gods. There are several themes in todays i went to heaven books. The question this book addresses is one with which the author has struggled all his life.
Heaven isnt pictured as a church or a synagogue but as a throne room of a great king. The levels are separated by gates which can be opened if the person observed certain rituals on earth, such as jihad, charity, fasting, and pilgrimage to mecca. Presumably, we will read, study, contemplate, and discuss gods word. Yoke of heaven is based on the weekly radio addresses that yeshayahu leibowitz had in israel that were compiled in book form. Absolutely nothing in genesis suggests that it was originally understood as given from god. The question this book addresses is one with which the. Who actually transmitted them to the jewish people is only a secondary concern.
The second book of enoch, meanwhile, states that both paradise and hell are accommodated in shehaqim with hell being located simply on the northern side. In this refreshingly fair, sophisticated, and engaging analysis of the doctrine of torah from heaven the jewish belief in the inerrancy and divinity of scripture, solomon surveys the history of jewish biblical interpretation, and concludes that every prior conception of this doctrine is lacking in either intellectual honesty or in its capacity to foster religious conviction. The books also relate the history of the jewish nation. It does not promise heaven for righteousness, nor does it threaten hell or the absence of heaven for sinfulness. As such, it made no sense to claim that god had ever spoken to a human being. The villagers are certain their rabbi flies up to heaven to speak with god on their behalf, petitioning god to write their names in the book of life. However, the rise of interest in mysticism in the last several decades has prompted a renewed discussion about the afterlife. In the mishnah, manna is treated as a natural but unique substance, created during the twilight of the sixth day of creation, 30 and ensured to be clean, before it arrives, by the sweeping of. The title of this book is torah from heaven and it was written by norman solomon. This is a translation of what is arguably heschels most important, ambitious, and monumental work.
Its how the torah can be a site for encountering god, for feeling called, compelled, commanded to live in a certain way, to do certain things, to feel in certain ways. And modern jewish thinkers have generally shied away from the topic. The first book of the torah is known in hebrew as bereishit in the beginning, because the opening lines describe how g. Torah is the world we enter when, through an act of active listening, we hear the voice of god. Torah from heaven is a book about deconstructing some basic jewish principles of faith. The book is a massive single volume, sadly without an index but containing excellent chapter introductions by the translator, conservative rabbi gordon tucker. In this period of intensified conflict, realize the course of history isnt determined by political power but by. Islams seven heavens islam adopted the idea of seven heavens from apocryphal jewish writings. Torah from heaven negates orthodoxy while offering absolutely no valid reasons for remaining as practicing members of the jewish community, if one accepts the premise of the book. Inspiring tales to nourish the heart and soul does precisely that nourish the heart and soul, and i recommend it highly to jews, people of all faith traditions, atheists and agnostics, rebels and anyone who cherishes the human spirit. Torah from heaven, a curious translation of heschels original three volumes torah min hashamayim or in his alternate english, the theology of ancient judaism, is, perhaps, his masterpiece.
Jesus said, heaven and earth will pass away, but my words will never pass away matthew 24. Simon rocker, jewish chronicle in this refreshingly fair, sophisticated, and engaging analysis of the doctrine of torah from heaven the. Moshe wrote this torah and gave it to the kohanim, the sons of levi 31. What the bible says about the heaven books tim challies. Traditional jewish religious belief speaks of a divinely revealed, perfect text, authoritatively expounded. After writing about this new genre of i went to heaven books, i received many comments and emails asking me about biblical examples of those who glimpsed heavenjohn in the book of revelation, paul in 2 corinthians, isaiah in his prophecy.
Another book was opened, which is the book of life. The first words of the bible are, when god began to create heaven and earth not god said to moses, when i began to create heaven and earth. Torah from heaven by norman solomon, 9781786940858, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. The talmud and the torah are mistakenly used interchangeably by nonjewish people. If a believer can tolerate the strong challenges presented in torah from heaven, the book is well written, most informative and quite enjoyable.
The word torah is repeated over and over in the closing chapters of sefer devarim, and the question arises what does this. Parshas yisro torah from heaven in this weeks parashah, the torah is given. Theres very little reconstruction to be found in it solomon provides his readers with many more questions than answers. In this weeks torah portion, nitzavim, we are taught, lo bashamayim hi the torah is not in heaven. God cannot write a book that shows sources, or takes part in a literary tradition, or that asserts counterfactual material, or that contains contradictions, because by definition, a perfect god must not produce such an imperfect product. The hebraic book of revelation part 6c torah to the tribes.
In other words, to put it more accuately, the real principle should not be called torah from heaven. In some ways, my deepest aspiration for this book is that readers will have moments of experiencing shamayim heaven in reading it. Known most widely for his role in the civil rights and peace movemen. Another word for this group of books is the pentateuch. In recent years, however, jewish scholars have proposed a rival theology of torah from heaven, one that retains a view of the torah the books.
892 1185 1421 1386 834 810 310 253 25 260 1103 455 1551 633 1153 441 1429 88 408 1011 747 1123 33 1254 722 1118 297 429 812 987 834 644 811 471